Managing samples and prototypes
How to run a sampling round so that six weeks later you still know which version is which, what you asked for, and whether you got it.
What a sampling round actually is
A round is one complete loop: you send a brief, the maker produces a version, you receive it, you give feedback. It takes between two and eight weeks depending on the craft and the distance, and the waiting is the part that wrecks your memory of what you asked for.
The vocabulary varies by trade, but the shape is usually:
- Proto · does the idea work at all? Often in the wrong material.
- Fit or wearing sample · is it right on a body, in the real material?
- Pre-production sample · exactly what production will be, made the way production will be made.
- Approved sample · the one you sign. Everything is measured against it.
Name versions so nobody guesses
The classic failure is three samples on a table and nobody certain which is the second and which is the third. Decide a naming rule before the first one arrives, and write it on the physical piece:
reference · version number · the date it arrived
Version numbers go up and never reset. If you reject V2 and the maker sends a corrected V2, it is V3 · a version number that means two different objects is worse than no version number.
Writing feedback a factory can act on
The difference between a round that fixes things and one that does not is almost entirely in how the feedback is written. Three rules:
- Measure, do not adjective. "A bit too chunky" produces another guess. "Band 2.4 mm, bring to 2.0 mm" produces the piece.
- One instruction per line, numbered. A paragraph gets half-read. A numbered list gets ticked off, and can be replied to line by line.
- Say what to keep. Feedback that only lists faults often loses something that was right · the maker rebuilds from scratch and the good part goes with it.
Mark photographs rather than describing locations in words. An arrow on an image costs ten seconds and removes a whole exchange of emails.
Photographing a sample properly
Not a beauty shot · a record. Flat, even light, plain background, a ruler or a coin in frame for scale, the version label visible. Both sides, and a close-up of anything you are discussing.
Do it the day it arrives. In four months you will be comparing V4 against a memory of V2, and a photo taken in good faith on a kitchen table in bad light will not settle anything.
The approved sample, and why it is sacred
When you approve a sample, that physical object becomes the reference for the whole production run. Keep it. Label it. Do not sell it, do not lend it, do not photograph the campaign with it and lose it.
If a delivery is wrong, the approved sample is what the conversation is about. Without it, it is your word against theirs, and nobody wins that.
Keeping track without a spreadsheet graveyard
What you need to be able to answer instantly, a season later:
- Which version is current, and which is approved?
- What did we ask for between V2 and V3, and did we get it?
- Who made it, what did it cost, how long did it take?
- Where are the photos of each version?
Most brands answer these from a spreadsheet, a photo roll and an email thread · three places that never agree. The information is not complicated. It is just scattered, and it scatters a little more every round.
Two things make the scattering slower. Give every version a reference that cannot be confused with another · how to create SKU codes covers the format. And write the feedback itself in a structure the maker can tick off · the sample feedback template does that for you, and keeps a copy you can file with the version.
If you are earlier than this · still choosing a maker, still deciding what to make · start with starting a jewellery brand or starting a clothing brand.
Every version, with its feedback, on the product itself
In Teseo, a piece carries its prototypes in order, the feedback written on each one, the photos of each version and the supplier making it. Which one is approved is a fact, not a memory.
Questions
How many rounds should I expect?
Two to four for a straightforward piece with a maker you know. More for a first piece with a new supplier, more again for anything with movement · a clasp, a hinge, a closure. Budget for three and be pleased at two.
Should I pay for samples?
Almost always, and it is normal. A sample takes the same setup as a production piece and often more hand work. Some makers credit sample costs against a first production order · worth asking before the quote, not after.
What goes in a tech pack?
Enough that someone who has never spoken to you could make the piece: measurements with tolerances, materials with references, construction notes, finishings, labelling, packing. Photographs and annotated drawings for anything words cannot carry.
The sample is wrong but close. Do I approve it?
Only if you would happily sell it. Production is rarely better than the sample you signed off · it is the ceiling, not the floor. "They will tighten it up in production" is the most expensive sentence in product development.